Should Gutters Match House, Roof, or Trim Paint Color?

June 1, 2007 § 20 Comments

Gutters are the functional part of your house and you don’t want to accent them in any way. Match the gutters to whatever color is behind them. If the gutters run along the trim, match the gutters to the trim color so the gutters disappear. If a gutter runs along the house, then match the gutter to the house color. That way the gutters will not be the first things you notice from the street.

Just like metal roofs, however, there are some fancy gutter materials like copper that will stand out against any trim and will become a design feature of your house. Just something to keep in mind.

§ 20 Responses to Should Gutters Match House, Roof, or Trim Paint Color?

  • doris palmer says:

    thanks for the the comme nt it does make sense. doris

  • karen says:

    hello barbara. i am trying to pick eavestrough/fascia/soffit colours for a side-hall 1920’s home. the bricks, which are quite dirty, are a mixture of dirty yellow, mossy green, some peachy-orange and dark gray-brown. the mortar is a neutral light brown. i have chosen windows in a very dark brown with more of a greenish tint than orange. the roof is a textured dark brown w/gray in it. i will try to send a picture – not sure how to do this in this format.
    i would like to keep the gutter/trough colour the same as the roof/windows and have an exact match. however, i don’t want that dark brown to extend into the fascia/soffits so i am thinking of a taupe with a slight green tint for those, as well as matching this colour for a small section of stucco and the small amount of wood trim on the front porch.
    is it odd to have the fascia and soffits a different colour than the troughs/gutters? i don’t want to put too many colours on the house but i don’t want it all to be brick and dark brown.
    thank you very much.

    • bmeglis says:

      Hi Karen,

      Not a problem at all to lighten up the soffit area and carry that color onto the rest of the trim. How about something like Ben Moore’s Wheeling Neutral HC-92 or Greenbrier Beige HC-79? Both of those have green undertones and should look really good with both your dark brown windows and the green tones in the brick. See what you think. You can always go creamier but I wouldn’t bring too much gray into the taupe — you’ll want the entry to be warm.

      Let me know it you need a front door color. ??

      Thanks again.

      Your Home & Color Coach

  • Heather says:

    I want to match the gutters/ eavestroughs to the wood trim- but- what can you paint the aluminum with that will withstand the elements?

    • bmeglis says:


      With a good primer, you can paint anything. Ask your paint store for a recommendation.

      Your Home & Color Coach

  • tmccrac says:

    Hi Barbara. Our house is a single-storey 50s ranch in Atlanta (hoping this info helps in picturing it). There’s a gabled porch centered in the front of the house, and the garage which we have now closed in is to the right (if you’re facing the house). The roof is a very dark, almost slate grey and we’ve just painted our house Benjamin Moore’s gettysburg grey, which in certain light almost has a slight green tinge. It says in the article to match the gutter to the house colour, but my concern is that our soffit is white. Will a gray gutter look strange against the white soffit? Should we paint the soffit and fascia gettysburg grey?

    Others are saying the gutter should match the trim. Our trim is white and our issue with a white gutter is staining from the elements and upkeep. We want it to be pretty but long-term low maintenance. What about matching the gutters to the roof? Could we have a slate gray gutter or black gutter? And if so, should we still paint the soffit to match the house? Our concern with matching gutters to the roof or having a darker gutter is that the roof already looks heavy on the house, dominating about 40-50% of the facade, and the top of the windows are very close to the eaves, which could make it feel like the gutters are almost concealing part of the windows, making the whole house look very top heavy. And we haven’t picked out the shutters, which judging by the way we’re selecting our colours is likely to be black or very dark. We’re confused. Please help!

    • Barbara Meglis says:

      Hi tmccrac,

      Match the gutter to the trim behind it so the gutter will disappear. Then if the downspouts run down the corner of the house along trim boards, keep the downspouts white too. But if the downspouts run down the middle of the house, paint them Gettysburg Gray again so they disappear. Unless you have fancy copper gutters, they are strictly functional and we need to conceal them as much as possible.

      Hope that helps.

      Your Home & Color Coach

  • Joyce Ingram says:

    We are renovating a small ’70s house. Word Picture: The exterior is brick of rose-beige/clay-colored tones. The windows have beige-colored frames and the roof is brown. I know the guttering should be the same color as the facia, but before we paint the facia, I would like to know if the facis and guttering should match the roof or the brick? Help!

    • Barbara Meglis says:

      Hi Joyce,

      I suggest matching the fascia/gutters to the window trim beige or a version of that. The fascia can contrast with both brick and roof. We do often paint downspouts to camouflage against the siding color but it’s not necessary if downspouts are on top of trim.

      Hope that helps.

      Your Home & Color Coach

  • Margaret says:

    HI Barbara,

    We have a cape fear brick with dogwood white mortar and are trying to pick a gutter choice that will blend in and make the gutters go away. Our shutters will be a version of BM blue ( haven’t decided but aiming for a layered french blue look) I have chosen a linen color but any ideas here?
    I have chosen a trim color which is custom blended and w grey/blue undertones so I am hesitant to pick a color that would contrast so playing it too safe with the linen?

    Thanks so much!

  • Greg says:

    Hi Barbara,

    We have a two story brown brick house with a grey mortar. We currently have beige gutters, facia, and soffit. We just changed out our windows to brown. Our garage door is pebble grey. I’m thinking of changing all the gutters, facia, soffit’s to brown. What do you think?


    • Barbara Meglis says:

      Hi Greg,

      You didn’t mention your roof color, but I do think it is a good idea to consolidate the color on your house and change what is currently beige to brown. Even though it’s dark, it sounds like an older home and the dark trim should look fine. I also like tying in the garage door and mortar colors. I hope you have a solid dark wood door, but if it’s painted, consider a lighter warm gray in a high gloss that will contrast nicely with the trim and brick. And you might switch to silver-toned metal for lights/mailbox/door hardware.

      Hope that helps.

      Your Home & Color Coach

  • Greg says:

    Thanks Barbara,

    The roof is a medium to dark brown. We’ve currently ordered a dark brown door (fiberglass) same as window trims. The house is approximately 30 yrs old. We thought that the brown would update the look. But, we were worried that we needed some pebble grey/beige (garage) to break it up somewhere.


  • Julie Clees says:

    Hi Barbara,
    I have a stained house the color of a pumpkin, white windows and dark brown fascia,soffet and spouting. My question is do I paint the trim around each window the dark brown or what they are all trim with wood around each window. What would look awesome?

  • Bruce boyd says:

    Hous e is tan and painted trim hunter green gutters are beige and white what to do

    • Barbara Meglis says:

      Hi Bruce,

      You might want to paint your trim white or even the house color (tan) and reserve the hunter green for shutters and the front door.

      Just a thought.

      Your Home & Color Coach

  • Nate Irvin says:

    I have a French country 2 story stucco new construction. I am looking at doing copper on the front of the home with collection boxes and doing either a musket brown or white/limestone color to match the rest of the house on sides and back? Have you seen this done or will it look like I took the cheap route.

    • Barbara Meglis says:

      Hi Nate,

      Although I don’t think it’s necessary to have the copper collection boxes to have an authentic-looking French country home, I do think that consistency is key to authenticity. An old French home would most likely have the same material all the way around. The “cheap route” happens when we make the view from the front only. Having said that, of course, I do look at “gutters and downspouts” as functional so I don’t have a problem camouflaging them with the house/trim color. But I would go all the way around with your decision.

      Hope that helps.

      Your Home & Color Coach

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Should Gutters Match House, Roof, or Trim Paint Color? at Your Home & Color Coach.



Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 475 other followers

%d bloggers like this: